Wednesday, May 14, 2008

Thought Experiment in Game Design

A short series I wrote elsewhere, reposted here.

Game Evolution from Scratch: A Thought Expirament (part 1)

Let's start with you basic of basics: you have a 'guy' that can walk around on the screen. Let's call him Joe. Now Joe can walk around, but there's nothing else in his world. We need to add some background elements like... trees. Uh-oh, Joe can walk right through the trees. That looks awkward, so we need to turn on collision detections to see whether Joe is trying to occupy the same space as the trees.

So now Joe can walk around and run into trees. Now he needs something to do like... catch bugs. So we populate Joe's tree-world with a variety of bugs and give him a net with which to catch them. We also give him an inventory screen to keep track of what he's caught.

Catching bugs for its own sake is all well and good, but Joe should get some kind of reward for his efforts. We can start by giving him and arbitrary score for each type of bug he catches. And maybe add a time limit to make things interesting. So now Joe spends his days catching as many bugs as he can in 3-minute intervals. He is allowed to write his initials on the High-Score chart whenever he beats his previous record.

Thus ends phase one of Joe's development with "Bug-Catcher Joe!" ... the original arcade version.

Game Evolution from Scratch: A Thought Expirament (part 2)

With "Bug-Catcher Joe" Joe is able to catch bugs for points in an effort to compete with himself. However for the console release I mean for his next evolution we can now save his progress and relieve him from his 3-minute repetition.

Except without a time limit Joe is now free to increase his score forever. Score for its own sake is fine, but we should give Joe some benchmarks to shoot for. Let's reward Joe with medals. He gets one silver medal for every 100 points and a gold medal for every 1000 points. Now Joe can brag about his medals.

After a while of his incessant bug-catching Joe is now laden with tons of medals, and their worth has depreciate some due to inflation of the market (which at this point consists entirely of himself). So we have a traveling merchant come to Joe's forest and set up shop. One would think that gold and silver medals (somehow gifted to Joe from powers unseen for his bug-catching diligence) should hold some kind of value and they do to this merchant. He will trade these medals for items Joe might find useful.

For example this merchant carries a silver bug-catching net that has a longer reach than Joe's normal wooden net. He also has a gold net which, while one would think gold being denser would be quite a bit heavier, actually lets Joe swing faster, thus aiding his catching of those hard-to-net fast bugs. The merchant also carries shoes which allow Joe to run faster.

The merchant also tells Joe of a legendary golden bug, whose speed and net-avoiding abilities frustrate even the best bug catcher. The merchant assures Joe, however, that if suitably equipped with the gold net and shoes he might one day catch this gold bug himself. Which Joe eventually does... then he gets a screen that says "Congratulations!" ... then the game starts over.

Thus goes "Bug-Catcher Joe 2" for the Game Entertainment System (GES) console.

Game Evolution from Scratch: A Thought Experiment (part 3)

When last we left Joe (at the end of "Bug-Catcher Joe 2") he had, presumably earned enough medals to get the equipment needed to catch the legendary golden bug. For his next adventure with memory prices becoming cheaper and the programmers becoming more familiar with the system we want to take Joe to a more interesting environment.

Joe's merchant friend returns and this time he has more variety in his inventory. Among his stock is an anti-venom potion. The merchant informs Joe that in this new local there are poisonous bugs that will kill Joe if he is stung, unless he quickly applies one of the aforementioned potions.

Also, gone are the old silver and gold nets. Now the merchant carries several varieties of wooden nets. One is made of light-weight wood for faster swinging. Another has an extra large opening for maximum bug-catching area. Another is made of aluminum with a steel mesh net (which the merchant informs Joe he will need for catching the new flaming/glow bugs). And lastly, a net with a finer mesh for catching elusive aquatic bugs.

The merchant also carries a new selection of footwear. Speed shoes for running faster, rubber boots for wading in rivers, and insulated boots to protect his feet from hot volcanic rock.

Joe ventures out to collect his bugs to earn medals for exchanging with his friendly merchant friend. Joe discovers that as the merchant said there are new and dangerous areas to explore.

There is now a river that host aquatic bugs. In th forest he can now overturn rocks to reveal bugs that may be hiding. Up on the ledges of a volcanic mountain (which a screen helpfully tells him he can't enter without insulated boots) there are fiery glow-bugs. A cave in the forest offers many new and different bugs, but also contains a larger number of poisonous bugs. He'll have to stock up on anti-venom potions before venturing there.

Joe also finds that each area contains a golden bug that appears at random, and is quite difficult to catch. The merchant informs Joe that upon catching each of these gold bugs he will be rewarded with a plaque, upon which Joe may write his initials, that the merchant will hang in his shop for all to see.

Thus Joe sets off to experience "Bug-Catcher Joe 3!"

Game Evolution from Scratch: A Thought Experiment (part 4)

With the release of the Super GES, Joe is propelled into the 32-bit era.

Apparently the merchant's shop became a favorite stop for other travelers because a whole town (more like a hamlet) has sprung up around it. There are now farms, houses, a school, a saloon, and a church. Among the townsfolk are Miss Monarch a school teacher, the Barkeep, and an old Professor. Joe has also got himself a little place at the edge of town. He has a bed (for healing his stats), a journal (for saving his game), and a shelf of jars to store his prized catches.

It turns out the old Professor is a retired entomologist who will pay Joe in local currency for his bugs (as the deus ex machina has ceased rewarding him with medals for some reason). Armed with his trusty net, Joe sets of to catch those bugs.

He discovers now that in addition to his meandering, random bug catching endeavors, the people of the town have chores quests for him to do.

Farmers will occasionally suffer infestations of locusts or crickets. While the Professor has now interest in these bugs the farmer will pay Joe for his efforts once all of them are caught.

Miss Monarch asks Joe to teach the kids of the town his bug-catching prowess. Though Joe and Miss Monarch seem to be the only two single adults in town no progress seems to be made in developing any kind of relationship between them. (Of course the fan artists online take care of that.)

The Barkeep apparently has discovered that a variety of bees is responsible for the excellent taste of his spirits and recruits Joe to gather them for him. While he doesn't offer cash he will give Joe free samples of his liquors (which somehow have a healing affect on Joe's body).

All the familiar upgrades from the previous game are available in the shop, as well as the promise of an award plaque on the wall.

As Joe leaves the peaceful town to go about his bug-catching routine his is confronted by a nefarious character who announces himself as the self-proclaimed "Bug Lord." He states his modus operandi life's work is to breed stronger, bigger, and more dangerous bugs so that one day all bug-kind might rule the world.

Though Joe questions the scope of this endeavor he decides it would be best to stop this man, as Joe doesn't wish his occupation to become more dangerous than it already is. The Bug Lord vanishes off screen before Joe can do anything and things return to normal.

Joe ventures into his familiar forest, catching his favorite prey along the way. In the furthest depths of the forest he comes upon a set of crates used as an artificial bugs nest. As Joe moves to investigate the Bug Lord appears and describes to Joe his latest bug-breeding experiment. Joe gets distracted by the thought of "bug-breeding" and doesn't really hear the rest of BL's monologue. As the Bug Lord wraps up his speech he opens the crates loosing red, scary beetle things. Joe decides he'd better catch these things before they spread an multiply.

After succeeding, Joe continues from area to are collecting more and more bugs of various attributes and monetary value. At the end of each area he discovers that the Bug Lord has been up to some other experiment and has to capture the resultant monstrosities.

After scouring the final area he finds no sign of BL, only the remains of some lab setup. Upon return to town he finds it has been overrun by creepy crawlies! The Bug Lord is there laughing it up as Joe sets about catching the pesky vermin. Shocked and angry at Joe's bug-catching feat the Bug Lord vows revenge and jumps off-screen, out of reach of our hero.

The townspeople all emerge from hiding and praise Joe for 'saving the town.' They throw a festival in his honor and the player is rewarded with a cutscene. Though the Bug Lord menace is over Joe is still free to hunt the ever-elusive gold bugs if he likes, and thus ends "Super Bug-Catcher Joe."

Game Evolution from Scratch: A Thought Experiment (part 5)

Joe gets some time off from his bug-catching (with the exception of "Bug-Catcher Joe 3" for the GES Portable) until the release of the "Super Bug-Catcher Joe 2."

Joe is back and a few new things have come about. The town has now named itself Jotown for the hero who saved it in the last game. It also now has a sister town called Riverbottom. All the familiar elements from the last adventure are there, and rumor is that the nefarious Bug Lord has been seen again in the vicinity of Riverbottom.

Now in addition to being able to overturn rocks in his search of bugs, Joe can shake trees, whack bushes with his net, and lay bait to drive his prey out of hiding. The world has newly invented night and day, which means that Joe can only capture certain bugs at night. The shop also sells a pair a "double-jump" shoes that will allow Joe to get to previously unreachable areas.

The new town of Riverbottom hosts its own merchant shop, which seems to try to out-do the Jotown shop in every way by offering bigger, faster, and more expensive versions of everything the Jotown shop carries. Riverbottom also has casino games in their bar, including a slot machine and dice games.

Thanks to the Bug Lord and his experiments, there are now bugs too resilient to simply catch with a net. Joe now carries a small club to daze these bugs before catching them. Some have been know to take three or more hits before becoming 'catchable.'

Joe goes about doing quests and leveling catching bugs to earn money for upgraded equipment (he apparently donated his previous equipment to charity). In the course of this he has a few run-ins with BL, culminating in the Bug Lord kidnapping a pair of children to feed to his newest breed of super-bugs, whom Joe saves from the bad nasties. Joe is rewarded for this feat with a festival and (at last) a kiss from Miss Monarch (whose first name it turns out is Mindy).

Aside from the stupid labyrinth level, the game is praised as being the best in the series so far.

Game Evolution from Scratch: A Thought Experiment (part 6)

Smartly avoiding the 'making old characters more violent and hardcore' phase of games, with the release of the GES64 Joe passes the baton, er... net to a youngster named Jim in "Bug-Catcher 64: Jim's Adventure."

Jim, under the mentorship of Joe assumes Joe's previous bug-catching duties (while Joe, I guess, pursues more important things... like hooking up with Mindy Monarch). Jim begins his adventure in the new 3D realm surrounding Jotown. This step into the third dimension, with the exception of some depth-perception problems, propels the bug-catching experience to new heights (and depths).

Jim now tangles with burrowing bugs, which he stabs at with a shovel, dislodging them from the ground, before catching them with his net. He must now also shoot down flying bugs with his slingshot, as they have all stopped flying at eye-level like they did in Joe's day.

The different types of bugs are grouped into families and colors, and the Professor must have one of each to be satisfied. Jim's main adversary is a rival bug-catcher/bully and his two cronies. Even though he is out-manned, Jim is up to the challenge of out-catching this jerk.

Liquor is no longer the healing agent of choice. Jim eats snacks and candies to replenish his health. When Jim wants to take a break from bug-catching there are now fishing and slingshot target shooting mini-games activities.

Jim's adventure culminates in a showdown with the creations of the infamous Bug Lord: a giant flame bug that shoots out its mini flame bug spawn that Jim must avoid/catch while luring the giant bug out onto a bridge over the river. Jim then cuts the ropes with his pocket knife, plunging the fiery bug to a watery doom.

While long-time fans are disappointed at Joe's absence from the spotlight, Jim is an instant hit with newcomers to the series.

Game Evolution from Scratch: A Thought Experiment (part 7)

The 'Bug-Catcher' series is conspicuously absent during the G-Cube era, having moved to the portable market. Though most of these were remakes of the previous titles, "Bug-Catcher Advance: Jim's Odyssey" offered an all-new world and featured Jim traveling to new islands in search of new bugs to catch.

The mascot Armor Beetle featured on all previous box art is replaced with the new Cutterfly bug, a hip and trendy design by a famed game artist brought onto the team after the franchise's acquisition by a new publisher. However a new Bug-Catcher game is scheduled to be released on the GES Gii next holiday season, with new motion controls.

Rumor is that the player will be able to choose between playing Joe, Jim, or Mindy in the new title.